Proposed Montgomery County Budget Threatens Massive Service Cuts

On the chopping block: the parks department and library services.

Montgomery County residents may yet avoid a tax increase for 2012, but only at the cost of massive reductions or eliminations of iconic county services and amenities.

A $384.8 million preliminary operating budget for 2012 would eliminate the county’s parks department and planning commission, while slashing or ending appropriations to the county library system, the Elmwood Park Zoo, Montgomery County Community College, and other institutions.

The budget, which was approved for advertisement Wednesday by the Montgomery County Board of Commissioners, “would change county government as we know it,” according to James Maza, the county’s deputy chief operating officer.

Proposed tax increase: $130 per homeowner

If taxes are not increased, the county needs to cut expenditures to cover a $44.4 million budget shortfall. Eliminating the parks department would save more than $5 million per year, and axing the planning commission would save an additional $2.6 million.

( for other dollar figures on cuts, as reported by Patch Wednesday. Attached PDFs to this story include the county’s proposed budget in brief, posted budget expenditure reductions from the general fund, and a summary of 2012 budget reductions.)

Cuts in appropriations to the county’s community college, library system, zoo, and other entities would trim more than $6 million from the budget.

Commissioners-elect Josh Shapiro and Leslie Richards “may not have been fully cognizant of the financial situation.”—Commissioner Bruce Castor

“I don’t want to eliminate the parks department or the planning commission. I don’t want the library to close,” said Commissioner Joe Hoeffel, who depicted himself as the proponent of a “middle ground” between the 28.6 percent tax increase favored by Commissioner James Matthews and a cost-cutting approach that he attributed to Commissioner Bruce Castor.

A 28.6 percent tax increase would translate to about $130 in additional annual taxes for the average county homeowner, according to figures provided by Randy Schaible, the county’s chief financial officer.

Castor, the only commissioner who will still be on the board when it is reconstituted in January, said he was open to the possibility of increasing taxes but noted that commissioners-elect Josh Shapiro and Leslie Richards had “boldly” campaigned on a promise to keep taxes at current levels.

Shapiro and Richards “may not have been fully cognizant of the financial situation,” Castor said. “They may still not be fully cognizant of it.”

Neither Shapiro nor Richards were in attendance at the meeting.

“It may be that after the press reports about [the budget] that the people will call the commissioners-elect and call the three of us and say, ‘We want our library, we want our legal aid, we want all of these things,’” Castor speculated.

‘Devastating’ to County Libraries

Kathleen Arnold-Yerger, executive director of the Montgomery County-Norristown Public Library, said by telephone Wednesday that losing $2.36 million from the county “would be devastating” to the operation of the library’s five locations and its four Bookmobiles.

“We’re open six days a week right now,” Arnold-Yerger said. “I don’t see how we could keep those hours. We wouldn’t be able to buy any new materials.”

According to Arnold-Yerger, the library’s annual budget is about $4 million, some $570,000 of which goes towards the purchase of books, media, and other resources for patrons.

‘Irresponsible and blind’

While libraries are among the services that would bear the brunt of the budget-cutting axe, no county department would emerge unscathed. Many departments would see their budgets cut 15 percent from 2011 levels, resulting in $16.6 million in savings.

County employees’ wages would be frozen at current levels, providing another $4.2 million. Staffing in the sheriff’s department and in courthouse security would be reduced, too, to save another $1 million.

Cutting the services as outlined in the preliminary budget “would be irresponsible and blind,” Matthews said.

Matthews cited the example of children who rely upon the library as their only information resource and means of accessing the Internet. “Are we going to shut that down? ‘Yeah, they’re not my kids.’ We can’t take that attitude,” he said.

Maza emphasized that the preliminary budget is “a platform on which to build a final budget.”

As a group, the commissioners signaled an eagerness for public feedback on the question of raising taxes. Matthews repeatedly pointed out that the county’s taxes had been among the lowest in the region for years and would remain so even if his proposed increase was adopted.

“This no tax increase budget shows the extreme pain to the county if we don’t raise taxes,” Hoeffel said.

The commissioners will meet again Dec. 7 at 10 a.m.

Jane Broderson December 01, 2011 at 01:04 PM
I for one am in favor of the proposed budget cuts. Cuts are always painful. No pain, no gain. Rather than wimping out and going back to the same old same old, we're just going to have to get resourceful...If the libraries can send me a "wish list" of books they were planning on buying with that half-million dollars, I would be willing to donate books and circulate emails within the community soliciting donations. Just tell me where to send/drop them off. In terms of the parks, we should round up volunteers, including local sports teams and their families, to help maintain the grounds. Commissioners-Elect, we elected you based on promises you made. Don't wimp out!! Perhaps we need to start occupying the township building to make our voices heard (JK on that part...) BTW, does anyone know how to email the Commissioners and Commissioners-Elect? We need to make our voices heard or it will be back to "business as usual"!!!
RICHARD LEVY December 01, 2011 at 01:44 PM
$130.00 per anum is not a lot of money. Pass the tax and let the new team clean up your mess. We do not want to cut our services nor do we want to become Philadelphia. We want lots of services and make Montco better so our investment in our property keeps it's value and our county is a great place to live.
J. Holmes December 01, 2011 at 06:15 PM
A message to the commissioners from the community- I think this sums it up: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmRvKM1KM6Q
Bill December 01, 2011 at 07:25 PM
We do not have to follow the outlandish trend of closing parks, libraries and eliminating services that typically serve the old and the very young. Sure, anyone can "take the pledge" but the wake created by cuts to save face are not acceptable to me as a taxpayer and concerned person. We need to take a mature and thoughtful approach to this situation. If taxes need to go up - and they haven't for three fiscal years - then we need raise taxes. I, for one, do not want to live in a county where politicos didn't have the fortitude to do what is right for the majority of the residents. I know there are folks who believe happiness is made by the rhythm of cut, cut cut. But that is not a good solution to a complex situation. And life in the real world is complicated. But it is good.
Cartman December 01, 2011 at 11:20 PM
This is great. Let me see if mature and thoughtful holds true when its framed a different way. Lets say you bought a pie bc it said "Cherry Pie - lower price" on the box. Then you discover its a shit pie. Do you stop and think - 'well, i've gotten good pies for the last 3 years. if i gotta eat some SHIT now - it's okay!!!' OR Should you try to get that baker arrested and/or thrown out of town? Why is it different for politicians? Why do we have to eat their shit? It is their job to figure this out. If you believe they can't do anything - well, I have some nice bridges to sell you ;-)


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something