Narberth United Methodist Church Closing, Property for Sale

The congregation is merging with a Bryn Mawr church in early 2013. Community groups in Narberth need a new home.

(Editor's note: This is the first article of a three-day series about a Narberth church closing next year. Visit Patch on Thursday and Friday for more coverage.)

's congregation has decided to sell the property and attend a Bryn Mawr church instead, and the effect will extend well beyond the walls of both buildings.

The 1-acre church property at Essex and Price avenues will go on the market within a week for an asking price of $1.7 million, said Narberth real estate agent John Duffy.

Members voted just before Easter to merge with another church and were soon welcomed by , said Narberth UMC pastor Lydia Munoz.

The United Methodist Church will discontinue the Narberth charter in May 2013, which means services must end by then. St. Luke pastor David Tatgenhorst said he expects the changeover to happen close to February 2013.

Many Narberth community groups who meet in the church are looking for new digs:

  • The Narberth Community Food Bank "has no intention of leaving the borough of Narberth," coordinator Gigi Tevlin-Moffat told Patch.
  • The Narberth Community Theatre is leaving Narberth: that can accommodate the final two shows of the 2012-13 season. Whether the name retains "Narberth" has not been decided, said theatre board president Steve Arcidiacono, and the Delaware County accommodation is temporary.
  • Staff of the New Horizons Senior Center are checking into possibly using the building on Sabine Avenue, said borough government manager Bill Martin.

A congregation that used to number in the hundreds has dwindled to about a dozen regular attendees, Munoz said. A new, more progressive congregation called Plumbline began in the church in 2009 and has about 30 to 40 regular attendees.

Munoz is pastor to both congregations; at St. Luke, she will conduct separate services for Plumbline while members of the original congregation can join their St. Luke counterparts for Tatgenhorst's services.

About 75 percent of all Narberth UMC members, Munoz said, are planning to make the eventual switch to St. Luke, which stands three miles away.

Narberth United Methodist Church was built in 1920; the parsonage next door went up in 1900. Another building across Essex Avenue was the sanctuary before 1920.

The property is zoned R-3 residential, so any developer that bought it would be free to replace the church buildings with homes. Church members would prefer to see the church they leave remain a church, according to Munoz and Duffy.

(Check back Thursday and Friday for more coverage of the Narberth United Methodist Church news.)

Michael Alexander July 25, 2012 at 12:29 PM
The current parsonage is a beautiful mansion that (needs a lot of work but) should be saved. There aren't too many houses left like this in Narberth, where once there were a lot more.
Peter January 10, 2013 at 10:41 PM
Does any one have any more news on this property? I live across the street and am very curious as to what the new buyer is going to do with the property. Another article said that they plan on turning the church into 11 condos. Does that mean they will knock down the church, or will they simply convert the same building into 11 different condos? Thanks!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »